DMCA Lawsuit re: YouTube Videos

YouTube logo

The DMCA claims

Ted Entertainment Inc. v. ByteDance, Inc., No. 3:25-cv-10933 (N.D. Calif., October 2, 2026)

The complaint alleges that ByteDance obtained YouTube videos for use in developing AI products such as MagicVideo and Seedance. Specifically, plaintiffs Ted Entertainment, Inc. and Matt Fisher allege that ByteDance circumvented technological measures controlling access to their YouTube videos, in violation of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA).

The technological measures allegedly used by YouTube include a “rolling cipher” signature system; IP-based blocking and rate limiting; brief session-bound streaming URLS; CAPTCHA challenges triggered by automated activity; and proof-of-origin tokens verifying requests from authorized client environments. The complaint also alleges that ByteDance’s acquisition of the videos violated YouTube’s terms of service.

The motion to dismiss

ByteDance filed a motion to dismiss. On October 2, 2026, the court denied the motion.

ByteDance had argued, among other things, that individual copyright owners lack standing because they do not own the technological measures that YouTube has implemented on its website. Basically, the argument was that if a copyright protection measure was circumvented, it was YouTube’s copyright protection measure, so only YouTube should have the right to complain about its circumvention. The court rejected that contention, holding that copyright owners whose works are protected by a third party’s technological measures are within the class of persons that Congress intended to protect by enacting a prohibition against circumvention of copyright protection measures.

The court did not rule on whether the use of YouTube videos to train AI is copyright infringement.

At the pleading stage, a motion to dismiss only challenges the sufficiency of a complaint to state a cause of action. It is not a determination that a plaintiff has proven its case, or that the allegations in the complaint are true.

Why It Matters

The ruling is significant because it supports an alternative strategy for copyright owners seeking redress when their works have been used by AI companies without their permission: Consider suing under the DMCA’s anti-circumvention provisions either in addition to, or as an alternative to, a copyright infringement claim.

For more information about the Copyright Act’s protections against copyright circumvention, read my previous post on the DMCA anti-circumvention provisions. The applicable statute is 17 U.S.C. § 1201.

Author: Thomas James

Thomas James (also known as Tom james) is an attorney located in Cokato, Minnesota (USA) with over thirty years of experience as a sole practitioner. His practice is focused on trademark and copyright registration and protection, small business and nonprofit organization formation, and applications for 501(c) tax-exempt status. Also an author and continuing legal education course developer and instructor. Admitted to the bar of Minnesota, the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals, and the United States Supreme Court. Also authorized to represent clients before the Copyright Office, the Copyrigh Claims Board, the USPTO (Trademark Office), and the Trademark Trials and Appeals Board. For information about legal representation regarding trademarks, copyrights, or busines law, visit ⁠the Law Office of Thomas James, https://tomjameslaw.com.

Leave a Reply